COLUMN

Why Windows Vista is superior to XP

By Brien Posey 13 Oct 2008 | SearchEnterpriseDesktop.com Tips on Desktop Management, Virtualization and Security Digg This!     StumbleUpon     Del.icio.us

Ever since Microsoft announced that it was going to stop selling Windows XP, the phrase "Save Windows XP" has become something of a battle cry. In spite of the nearly global backlash against Windows Vista, though, I personally think that Vista is a better operating system than Windows XP. I realize that many of you are probably calling me an idiot right now, but hear me out before you flame me.

Why such a backlash?

For those of you who may be wondering why there is such a backlash against Windows Vista, it's primarily related to three issues: performance, hardware compatibility and software compatibility.

Windows Vista performance

Desktop management tips from SearchEnterpriseDesktop.com Sign up for our additional editions of SearchEnterpriseDesktop.com's Desktop Management Adviser to learn more about desktop management, security and virtualization.

One of the biggest arguments from Vista's critics is that if you were to take two identical PCs and install Windows XP on one and Windows Vista on the other, Windows XP is going to perform better. In fact, I recently received an email message from one reader who told me that he purchased Windows Server 2008 and uses it as a workstation operating system instead of Windows Vista because it performs better (Microsoft must love that guy).

I am not going to insult anyone's intelligence by telling you that Vista outperforms Windows XP. It just doesn't. What I will say, though, is that Vista's performance is not usually an issue on most newer computers.

In a way, the same thing could also be said about Windows XP. Before Windows XP was released, Windows 98 was the dominant operating system. When Microsoft released Windows XP, a lot of people complained that the new operating system was bloated and that it did not perform as well as Windows 98. Over time, hardware became more powerful and the operating system's performance eventually ceased to be an issue. I believe that the same thing will happen with Windows Vista.

Vista hardware compatibility

Another reason why many companies shy away from using Windows Vista is because of hardware compatibility concerns. Admittedly, Windows Vista requires a lot more CPU power, memory and disk space than Windows XP does. There are also issues with the unavailability of drivers for legacy hardware, especially if the hardware is something obscure or highly specialized.

In some ways, Windows Vista has Windows XP beat in the hardware compatibility department. Although there has been a 64-bit version of Windows XP for many years now, finding 64-bit drivers for XP has always been a bit of an issue. Initially, the only 64-bit drivers you could get for Windows XP were the ones that came with the operating system. Even though hardware vendors started releasing more 64-bit drivers for Windows XP over time, finding drivers can still be a challenge.

Things are different, however, with Windows Vista. Although Vista comes in 32-bit and 64-bit versions, it is obvious that Microsoft is working hard to get everyone to make the move to 64-bit. Also, the 64-bit version of Vista comes with plenty of drivers. On occasion I have needed to download 64-bit drivers for some of my more specialized hardware, and on only one occasion have I ever had any trouble finding 64-bit drivers for Vista. I can't say the same for Windows XP.

Vista software compatibility

Probably the one concern that has hurt Windows Vista more than any other is the software compatibility issue. Many applications that run just fine under Windows XP will not run under Windows Vista. Often, the operating system can be tweaked to allow legacy applications to run, but not always. Running newer applications isn't really an issue anymore, because just about every software vendor now makes Vista-compatible versions of their applications.

Personally, I had quite a few problems with software compatibility when Vista was first released. I just could not get three applications I use on a regular basis to run in Vista. Since then, these applications have all been updated and software compatibility has not been a problem for me in quite some time.

Although software compatibility is something you certainly have to consider when making a decision about whether or not to upgrade to Vista, it is important to remember that the reason why some compatibility problems exist is because of Vista's new security model. In my opinion, this new security model more than makes up for any compatibility problems that may result.

Look for part two of Brien Posey's column on why Windows Vista is a better operating system than Windows XP.

About the author: Brien M. Posey, MCSE, has received Microsoft's Most Valuable Professional Award five times for his work with Windows Server, IIS and Exchange Server. He has served as CIO for a nationwide chain of hospitals and healthcare facilities, and was once a network administrator for Fort Knox.

Tags: Windows XP management,  Windows Vista management,  Windows Vista security issues, updates and alerts,  Windows XP security issues, updates and alerts,  VIEW ALL TAGS

Digg This!     StumbleUpon     Del.icio.us

RELATED CONTENT Windows XP management New Enterprise Desktop e-zine Reduce unapproved device driver installs via Group Policy in XP, Vista Windows operating system management for the IT pro Managing single sign-on security burdens in Windows Creating the Secure Managed Desktop Managing Windows folders with Redirected Folders Managing folders inside the Windows documents folder Identity and Access Management Security School Regaining lost functionality in the Windows XP Recovery Console Recover from configuration changes to Windows XP Windows Vista management Combining folder redirection with roaming profiles IPv6 protocol, Windows Vista features simplify peer ad-hoc networking When to move off XP, onto Windows 7 Reduce unapproved device driver installs via Group Policy in XP, Vista Using Reliability and Performance Monitor to gauge system stability Windows Vista management tutorial Windows operating system management for the IT pro Managing Windows Vista: Top 10 tips of the year Minasi says Vista SP1 solves problems, adds new ones Does Vista's strong security make it better than XP? Windows Vista security issues, updates and alerts Ten ways to sell security to management Improve Windows security with our top 10 tips Windows Vista management tutorial Minasi says Vista SP1 solves problems, adds new ones Does Vista's strong security make it better than XP? Are Windows Vista's features silencing critics? Managing single sign-on security burdens in Windows Top 10 ways to improve Windows Vista security A Windows security checklist for IT managers Unauthenticated vs. authenticated security testing

RELATED GLOSSARY TERMS Terms from Whatis.com − the technology online dictionary XP key changer  (SearchEnterpriseDesktop.com)

RELATED RESOURCES 2020software.com, trial software downloads for accounting software, ERP software, CRM software and business software systems Search Bitpipe.com for the latest white papers and business webcasts Whatis.com, the online computer dictionary